Ever wondered how a threesome might affect your relationship? You’re not alone! These Reddit users opened up about their experiences, and their stories range from unexpected benefits to absolute chaos. Read on for the raw, unfiltered truth—plus tips if you’re considering adding a third partner.
1. “Our First Threesome Saved Our Relationship”
u/HeroOfHearts shared: “I made a comment about her friend during a fight, and shockingly, she made it happen. My partner is bi, and this was a way for her to explore her sexuality without feeling guilty. We teamed up to make it work, and it brought us closer. Now, we’ve done it a few more times. It’s become something we enjoy together.”
Takeaway: Sometimes, unexpected situations can turn into bonding opportunities—if you’re both open to them.
2. “Balancing Emotions Was the Hardest Part”
According to u/UnableFalcon6471, “My ex and I approached it carefully. We picked a third party we weren’t too close with, to avoid awkwardness. The hardest part? Making sure both women felt valued equally during the experience. You don’t want anyone feeling left out!”
Pro tip: It’s all about managing emotions and keeping communication open.
3. “She Had an Earth-Shattering Orgasm—And I Had to Deal With It”
u/CreatedfortheNJCutie said, “We planned it all—rules, communication, everything. But I had to brace myself for the possibility that she’d enjoy the other guy’s touch. It’s not easy seeing your partner in that way, even if you agreed to it.”
Reality check: Fantasy can be fun, but make sure you’re ready for the real-life feelings that might follow.
4. “The Threesome Led to a Huge Revelation”
u/thesettledpirate confessed, “I was the third for a couple, and while it was hot, it led to a big revelation—the husband came out as gay. They ended up divorcing, and I always had mixed feelings about my role in it.”
Lesson learned: Adding another person can open up unexpected truths about yourself or your partner.
5. “It Was Hot—But the Awkwardness Lasted Longer”
For u/lunallee212, a threesome with her sex and his friend seemed exciting—until the morning after. “Seeing his friend after that night was just… weird. Even though it was fun in the moment, I wouldn’t do it again.”
Consider this: Temporary excitement can lead to long-term awkwardness if boundaries aren’t clear.
6. “We Survived Because We Set Boundaries”
Longtime swingers u/shadowpornacct and their partner navigated the world of group sex by setting strict boundaries. “We communicated constantly, set limits, and debriefed after every encounter. It wasn’t just about the physical—it was about protecting our connection.”
Pro tip: Boundaries and communication are non-negotiable when exploring outside the norm.
7. “She Kissed the Third More Passionately Than Me”
One user, u/eyelikeroundthings, confessed that the threesome his girlfriend proposed had an unexpected impact. “Watching her kiss another woman with more enthusiasm than she’s ever kissed me? That hurt. And she mentioned my involvement with the other woman way more than I expected. It left a mark.”
Takeaway: What seems thrilling in the moment can leave lasting impressions that are hard to shake off.
8. “Our Relationship Needed This”
u/mikess314 shared that he and his girlfriend engage in threesomes a few times a year. “It’s definitely intense to watch your partner with someone else. But it works for us because we use it as a way to reconnect and build trust.”
Advice: Know your own limits and make sure your relationship is strong before taking this step.
9. “I Wasn’t Attracted to the Third—Big Mistake”
u/LimpAd5888 learned the hard way: “I went along with it because I was 17 and thought I’d be into it. But I just wasn’t attracted to her friend, and it made the whole experience uncomfortable.”
Lesson: If you’re not attracted to everyone involved, it’s probably not going to be a great experience.
10. “Our Connection Grew Stronger After 20 Threesomes”
u/mr_mcclane and his partner found that threesomes were the secret ingredient to a stronger bond. “We’ve had about 20 MFF threesomes, and our relationship is better than ever. The key? Our relationship was rock-solid before we started. Bringing others into the bedroom can amplify what’s already there.”
Hot tip: Use these experiences to enhance your relationship, not to patch up existing cracks.
11. “The Threesome Was Fun, But It Left Scars”
For u/eyelikeroundthings , the mental replay of his girlfriend with another woman was hard to erase. “Even though it was a fantasy, seeing her so into it bothered me more than I expected.”
Keep in mind: Visual memories can stick around longer than the thrill.
12. “Communication Is Everything in Group Play”
According to u/JTOtown, “My partner and I always made sure to communicate before, during, and after every encounter. It’s the only way to ensure everyone’s on the same page and that no one feels left out.”
Pro tip: Clear communication is the difference between a great experience and a disaster.
13. “Our Relationship Thrives on Threesomes”
For u/kheroth, adding other partners keeps things exciting. “We’ve been in an open relationship for five years. Threesomes and dating separately work for us because we’re completely open about what we want.”
Takeaway: Honesty and openness are key when exploring non-traditional relationship dynamics.
14. “We Didn’t Know What We Were Getting Into”
u/JesusMakesMeLaugh shared, “We accidentally fell into a threesome with my wife’s best friend. It wasn’t planned, and afterward, we both were like, ‘What just happened?’ We didn’t talk about it much after that, but we’ve stayed happily married.”
Advice: Spontaneity can be fun, but it’s better to have a plan.
15. “Preparation Made All the Difference”
u/waythrow13579 was determined not to let things go sideways. “We researched all the possible outcomes before we even considered adding a third. It wasn’t about being paranoid—it was about making sure we were prepared.”
Pro tip: Don’t dive in headfirst—know what you’re getting into.
16. “Taking It Slow Saved Us”
u/talentsmart shared, “It took two years before we actually tried a threesome. By then, we were fully prepared and on the same page. It made all the difference.”
Lesson: Patience pays off—don’t rush into anything you’re not ready for.
And Finally, “The Truth About Threesomes and Relationships”
So, what’s the final verdict from those who’ve been there? Threesomes can be a thrilling way to explore new dynamics, but they’re definitely not for the faint of heart. Whether it’s a way to spice things up or a potential minefield of emotions, the outcome depends on your relationship’s foundation and your ability to communicate.
Thinking about trying it yourself? Let us know in the comments! Share this article with friends who might be curious, and don’t forget—communication is everything.
